Why 3-star reviews matter more than you think
Summary
Three-star reviews get ignored because they are neither crisis nor praise. They are the most useful feedback a venue receives, and they deserve a proper reply.
Three-star reviews are the most useful feedback a venue gets, and most of them go unanswered.
When did you last read your 3-star reviews? Most venues watch the top and the bottom of the scale closely and skip the middle, on the assumption that 3 stars barely moves the score and that nobody reads them anyway.
Both assumptions are wrong. Three-star reviews may be small in volume, but they are the highest-value feedback you receive.
Why 3-star reviews matter
A 3-star review is usually a mixture of negative and positive feedback in one place, written in a calmer, more neutral tone than either extreme. Anger and delight both exaggerate; a fair review with well-written detail tells you what actually happened.
That makes it the most useful input your business gets. For you, it turns straight into action points for the guest experience. For potential customers reading through your reviews, it is the most credible account on the page, because it sounds like a person rather than a fan or a feud.
How to respond to 3-star reviews
As with every review, respond as soon as you can. The tricky part is the balance: take the praise and acknowledge that something needs your attention. Your reply has to address the positive and the negative comments equally.
Personalise every response. Four core elements give you a framework:
1. Acknowledgement
Thank the reviewer for their feedback, using their name.
2. Appreciation
Thank them for the positive part and reflect it back: name the specific thing they enjoyed rather than a generic 'glad you had a great time'.
3. Apologise and take it offline
Move to the areas that fell short, apologise for the parts of the experience that missed the mark, and take the recovery handling offline, where you can actually fix things.
4. Follow up and invite them back
Communicate the steps you have taken based on the feedback, and invite them back to see the difference. It shows you took them seriously.
A response built on those four steps could look like this:
'Hi [name], thank you for taking the time to share your feedback.
We're glad you enjoyed [positive]. We're sorry to hear about [negative]; it isn't the standard we aim for, and we've [what you changed] so it doesn't happen again.
If you'd like to talk it through, email or call us on the details below. We'd love to welcome you back soon.'
Make review management easier for you and your staff with our reviews feature. Get in touch to find out more.
See it running on your venues
One unified guest record across Wi-Fi, bookings, reviews and loyalty, and the marketing that acts on it.